Actually, that's an interesting feature of the boards I had to get used to. Unlike the old boards, the "quote" function here only quotes the original content of the prior message. If you want to quote stuff from multiple messages, you need to hit that little 'quote' icon right next to the Quote word...
"My god! Do we really suck, or is this guy really that good?" - Mr Hertz - Shoot 'Em Up
"My god! Do we really suck, or is this guy really that good?" - Mr Hertz - Shoot 'Em Up
Magic Eye image: